OpenAI Counters Apple Lawsuit Citing Security Flaws and Vague Trade Secret Definitions

OpenAI argues Apple’s weak access controls and undefined secrets undermine theft claims, asserting the suit aims to hinder AI hardware development rather than protect IP.

Woofun AI reports that OpenAI has filed a response to Apple’s trade secret lawsuit, arguing that deficiencies in Apple’s information security and employee offboarding procedures invalidate its legal claims. OpenAI submitted evidence showing an Apple manager accessed former engineer Chang Liu’s personal iCloud account post-departure to transfer files and seek technical advice, highlighting failures to revoke system access.

The filing asserts Apple failed to specify alleged stolen secrets, citing only broad categories like component manufacturing and supplier relationships. OpenAI contends the lawsuit intends to restrict its AI hardware expansion rather than protect intellectual property, stating it builds distinct products and attracts talent through innovation appeal. Apple previously sued in July, alleging confidential information acquisition via former employees, and recently requested expedited discovery, suggesting broader internal involvement.